Alien Earth: Broken Promises and The Monster That Remains
- Oct 9
- 3 min read
Darkmeter 5.5 🐦⬛
Alien Earth arrives bearing a massive vow: xenomorphs on Earth, just months before the original ’70s film. It promises limits, survival, a fear you can breathe. But that promise—sold brilliantly, to be fair—doesn’t always hold once the screen goes dark.
It steps into the Alien universe with respect for its icons, yes, but it doesn’t reach the viscous emotion earlier entries managed to provoke. It beats, though far from the chest.
From Prometheus to the Small Screen: A Dangerous Identity
Ridley Scott and the studio have spent years pushing to expand the myth.
With Prometheus they opened a different vein: drama, psychology, cosmic horror. That compass was meant for television. The intention is there, the atmosphere peeks through… but the identity fragments. At times, Alien Earth could be called anything else and little would change.
That has a positive side—the story tries to stand on its own—but it also steps away from what mattered most, what a fan expects to find when the franchise’s metallic growl begins: horror with awe.
When the Jaw Locks
The first two episodes are sharp. Tension, clarity of premise, a promise of descent… then the floor gives way. The narrative becomes contaminated by convenient decisions, the camera loses its pulse, and terror turns into noise.
Discomfort no longer springs from stalking but from the linework itself: characters acting by script more than instinct, scenes that cannot find their breath in the dark, and inconsistencies too convenient—beyond a Mary Sue or a shark jump.
Hope in the Void
Amid the wreckage, there are sparks that light the way. Timothy Olyphant composes an unsettling synthetic—devoid of soul and yet mysteriously human—where every gesture reads the atmosphere.
Essie Davis embodies a scientist‑mother who drives progress with heart and moral edge. There lies Alien’s DNA: humanity against the inhuman. How far are we willing to go—does our advancement bring us closer to our primitive self?
The Void
Outside of those flashes, the rest comes apart. The arcs of several protagonists are held together with pins: motivations that change for convenience, decisions that contradict what has been established, and dialogue that explains where it should reveal with solid writing, acting, and atmosphere.
Sydney Chandler may deliver a personal best—competent, but not enough to carry the dramatic weight.
Alex Lawther, as the “medic/soldier” brother, ends up hollowed out: the role asks for composure, skill, and nuance, and the performance doesn’t reach it. When every gesture hits the same note, suspense deflates.
The Darkest Point
Direction doesn’t find a recognizable pulse either. The staging oscillates between Prometheus’s thesis and Alien’s raw brutality without a bridge to weld them. Some scenes ask for silence and surgical cuts but receive lines that don’t make sense; others crave vertigo and are filmed like mere errands to turn the project in.
The result is a diffuse identity: at times essay, at times theme park, rarely Alien. And when the series abandons its identity, the monster stops biting.
The camera betrays the practical effects: framings that reveal the suit, choreography that exposes the puppet strings. It’s not a lack of craftsmanship, it’s a lack of gaze. With a stricter visual grammar, many of these errors would be hidden; here, they are exposed.
Rhythm, Progress, and The Void Between Episodes
There is a cliffhanger, of course, “significant.” But half the journey feels immobile. Eight episodes that could have been four, perhaps a miniseries, perhaps a better‑concentrated first movement. Luck weighs more than causality, and forward motion dissolves in the edit.
The Question That Bites
Even so, something keeps beating. The idea. Who are the real monsters? The xenomorphs who hunt by primal impulse? The synthetics, mirrors of our desire to play god? Or us, who manufacture the conditions for our own fall?
That dilemma—which at least remains—deserves a second chance if another season arrives in this same timeline or another expedition to the small screen.
The Weight of A Broken Promise
Alien Earth isn’t the bottom of the abyss, but it is a serious stumble for a first television incursion.
Hopefully the confirmed crossovers with Predator and other media set a course and return a voice of its own, because the promise can still be kept if the creature finds its home beyond the end of space.
Comments